The Superiority of Voting For Principle Over Not Voting at All
As I have said in comments on several other blogs, I felt the that the most principled vote for libertarians and paleoconservatives in 2008 was for Chuck Baldwin. Many in these philosophical camps have advocating not exercising the franchise, faced with the choice of a left-socialist and a right-socialist. However not voting, which leaves no trace, doesn’t suffice to register a protest. It will be interesting to see what the total votes of third parties will come out to in the next couple of days. A high vote would express a dissastisfaction with the present two party system. On the other hand a non-vote could be interpreted as either apathy or protest, an ambiguity which of course the supporters of the system would interpret to their advantage.
As much as I respect the persons and positions of the non-vote strategists, this is likely to be a bad year for them. This campaign has generated tremendous energy, particularly among the Obama side, but also among the Republican base after the nomination of Sarah Palin as McCain’s running mate. Hopes that a mounting historical trend of nonparticipation in the electoral process would delegitimate the political system are likely to be dashed in the immediate future.
About Baldwin I have no regrets. The Constitution party is a half-baked idea who’s time has yet to come, and probably never will as long at it is run by factuous amatures. But Baldwin addressed issues with dignity and using the rhetorical conventions which were once the halmark of the American republic. Even on those issues where I disagree with him he has argued with logical coherence…never pandering to his audience, but rather trying to evoke in them a renewed committment to higher principles. In short, a political strategy which is guaranteed to result in defeat, since it over-, rather than underestimates the intelligence and morality of the electorate. John McCain has persued the opposite strategy…and he is going down in defeat anyway…taking his honor with him.
For that reason I don’t consider my vote for the Baldwin/Castle ticket wasted…quite the opposite!
